Alabama probably averages 4 first rounders per year? Which means there are currently 8 future 1st round picks on the Bama team. How many first round picks are on the Giants roster? Even worse is that Alabama has a huge advantage at the most important position (QB) is better than the current Giants QB. The reason that the NFL teams don't have all americans at every position is because 1) they don't get unlimited 1st round picks and 2) the salary cap prohibits that. We just had a discussion about why the Eagles traded a current 1st because you want to layer your big contracts. That's not a thing in the NCAA.
Yes, Dickerson might not have started. That doesn't really matter as he was clearly NFL caliber.
This is a pic before these WRs were drafted:
These 21 year olds aren't strong enough to play in the NFL?
Also, this whole thing started as a joke making fun of the Giants.
EDIT: I'll expand a little more.Waddle, Surtain, Smith, Mac Jones, Dickerson, and Barmore would have started for the Giants last year (that's only the players that were drafted and doesn't involve who is currently on the Bama roster). It's also omitting Najee Harris only because of Barkley... even though Harris had 1200 yards rushing and 7 TDs as a rookie.